UPDATE: The Turkeys That Terrorized Erie Street In Caledonia Are No More

They caused a pretty big raucous and made the Village President (and others) pretty mad, but the Caledonia Police solved the problem.

UPDATE: During a Village Board meeting on Dec. 6, 2011, Village President, Ron Coutts, received a bottle of Wild Turkey bourbon from a resident, who was poking a little fun at him for his intolerance of turkeys in his yard. While Coutts gave the bottle back, he explained to the audience how the turkeys had become a nuisance.

ORIGINAL STORY: Two wild turkeys that chased people into their garages and caused traffic back-ups in the 5800 block of Erie Street won’t be a problem anymore.

The Wisconsin Department of Natural Resources issued a permit to the  to shoot the birds on Saturday morning.

Ron Coutts, the Village President, told Toby Schey, the chief of police for Caledonia, last week that the turkeys had attacked him inside his garage and he used a three-wood golf club to fend them off to get inside his house. Coutts told Schey he had called the DNR to see if they could set a trap to catch the turkeys, but he was told they wouldn’t set up a trap and that he would need to either just shoo them away or call the federal government.

“What are the feds going to do? I asked them. I told them then they just might as well arrest me right now,” Coutts said.

A number of neighbors in the area had been annoyed because the birds defecated on their porches. At one point Coutts said he couldn’t even get his mail because the turkeys were hanging around the mailbox and the mailman refused to deliver the mail.

According to a report by the Caledonia Police Department, one of the officers said one of the male turkeys had attacked his squad car while he was driving and when he slowed down, the turkey pecked at his front tires. Other officers had also complained of the same thing.

A few weeks ago traffic was backed up on Erie Street when a WE Energies employee had to shoo a turkey away from standing in the middle of the road because it had stopped the flow of traffic.

To resolve the problem, a police officer on Friday called Kevin Mickelberg, regional warden for the DNR, and told him about the problem. Mickelberg issued an authorization to remove or destroy animals causing damage or nuisance, according to the police report.

At 8 a.m. Saturday morning, the two turkeys ran into the roadway and started pecking at the officer’s police squad. A few minutes later they began to follow the police squad near the south playground area by Olympia Brown. When the officer got out of the car, the turkeys started attacking the officer and he shot them with his shotgun.

Sgt. Brian Wall said he’s not sure what happened to the turkeys after they were shot.

Denise Lockwood December 07, 2011 at 05:04 AM
So... did the turkeys at least get eaten?
Colleen December 07, 2011 at 03:44 PM
According to the cbs story posted above by Heather, they ended up in a dumpster. Everyone I have discussed this with, disagrees with how this was handled...
bernie December 07, 2011 at 11:56 PM
sure glad I moved away from caledonia killer turkeys are just to much. you have got to be kidding, the cops who told me I was over reacting to bullet holes in the house and garage are afraid of two birds and had to shoot them is unbeleiveble.Maybee they should look into feather peircing bullets as standard equip.
caledonia resident 190 December 08, 2011 at 03:32 AM
I question some parts of Coutts' story. The mail carrier for the area says the turkeys never prevented his delivery of the mail......I think they irritated Coutts and so he got rid of them. If you live in Caledonia, you should expect to have wildlife around.
Kelli Kelemen December 08, 2011 at 02:03 PM
I am really going to miss these turkeys :(


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »